Article Bottom AD
4 min read

MCA's draft makes CSR impact assessment voluntary, ending the mandate for firms with ₹10 crore+ obligations

MCA's draft makes CSR impact assessment voluntary, ending the mandate for firms with ₹10 crore+ obligations

CSR impact assessment · independent impact assessment, CSR outcomes, CSR reporting

New Delhi, Nov 21, 2026: India's largest CSR spenders may no longer have to commission independent impact assessments of their projects. Draft amendments to the Companies (CSR Policy) Rules, 2014, released by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) on November 11, 2026, would make impact assessment voluntary for every company, "irrespective of their CSR obligation."

What changes

Today, Rule 8(3) requires companies with an average CSR obligation of ₹10 crore or more in the previous three years to have an independent agency assess the impact of their larger projects. This applies to projects with outlays of ₹1 crore or more that were completed at least a year before the study. The requirement has applied since the 2021 amendments to the CSR Rules.

Under the draft, any company could still commission a study. If it does, the report must still go to the board and be attached to the annual CSR report. The limit on booking assessment costs as CSR stays the same: 2% of that year's CSR spend or ₹50 lakh, whichever is higher.

A senior MCA official told The Economic Times the aim was to "make CSR compliance easier."

Easing on one side, tightening on the other

The draft also makes the rules stricter. It adds four exclusions from CSR, including one-off events, funding government schemes and corpus contributions. It also sets up a cancellation regime for implementing agencies that misuse funds. So the overall push is to control what money goes into, rather than to require proof of what it achieves.

Amit Agarwal of Nangia & Co LLP said CSR would be judged "not by how much is spent, but by what it achieves." (as reported by PSU Watch)

Vinod Kothari Consultants takes the opposite view. It says making assessment optional undermines its purpose and goes against the High-Level Committee on CSR, which encouraged need and impact studies. The firm has proposed that companies at least be required to disclose any voluntary studies they carry out.

What the data shows

The mandate has produced results. A December 2024 KPMG review of Nifty 250 companies found that 91 of the 114 companies required to do impact assessments, about 80%, disclosed them and gave access to the full reports. Only 35% had consulted all key stakeholder groups.

The change also follows MCA's May 2026 amendment, which let companies put up to 10% of their CSR spend into zero coupon zero principal instruments on Social Stock Exchanges. That amendment exempted those investments from impact assessment.

What companies should do

CSR heads and boards should decide now whether to keep running independent assessments. Investors and ESG raters may still expect outcome data in BRSR and annual reports. Comments on the draft can be sent through the MCA e-consultation module until December 11, 2026.

Tags: CSR impact assessment, Rule 8, CSR reporting, BRSR, MCA draft, CSR governance

AD Banner After Article

Top Stories

Featured